This is a post I’ve been wanting to write for a while. In fact, it stems from something I noticed way back in August of last year. After digging for answers and even a couple attempts at contacting their customer support, I’ve concluded that LinkedIn is by far the creepiest social network. The primary reasons LinkedIn is the mustached, trench coat and wire frame glasses wearing mouth breather of the internet are the “People You May Know” and “People Also Viewed” features.
Let’s begin with the “People You May Know” feature. Every time I sign in, I’m startled by one of the names they suggest. My reactions range from “How did you know I know them?” to “There’s no way you should know I know them” to “Ok, I don’t know that person, but they have the same name as someone I do know, and you shouldn’t even know that.”
Let’s begin by showing some examples of the names that have popped up under the “People You May Know” sidebar widget (the names have been changed to protect the “people I may know”), along with a brief description of their association with me:
Steve happens to be my fiancée’s stepfather. Steve has a total of 6 connections, none of which are 2nd or 3rd degree connections with any of mine, he lives an hour away from me and is in a completely different industry. I’m not even friends with my fiancée on Facebook…
Heather happens to be a girl I dated way back in high school. Cute, right? We’re friends on Facebook but that’s pretty much the extent of it. The only problem is, this person is the wrong Heather. This Heather has a different profession and lives on the other side of the country. She has barely any connections and no discernible link to me other than the name she shares with someone I do know.
This is the maiden name of my aunt who was married into the family years ago. However, my aunt of course has a different name now, isn’t on LinkedIn, and isn’t a CPA. I’m pretty perplexed on this one. This person lives across the country and has zero connections.
At this point I think I have a theory on what’s going on here. Even though I have no shared connections, school, company, or industry, LinkedIn is using the search and viewing history of other people to make assumptions on who I may know. In other words, if someone searched for both of us, we might know each other.
Makes sense, right?
Enter Herman & Doug…
A couple more “People I May Know” included Herman and Doug. Herman follows me on Twitter, but happens to live in the Netherlands. We’ve never had any other association. Doug lives in New York and contacted me through my personal site a year ago. We exchanged a couple emails and that was it. We share no groups, no connections or anything else.
Okay, so maybe they are getting Twitter data somehow? How they knew about the guy I emailed, I still have no idea…
But wait, according to LinkedIn’s Help Center on the People You May Know feature, these suggestions are based on just 2 factors (straight from the Help Center page):
- Commonalities between you and other members. For example, you may have common connections, similar profile information and experiences, work at the same company or in the same industry, or attended the same school.
- Members you’ve imported from other address books in your Contacts list.
I don’t currently and haven’t previously used the Imported Contact feature and as described above, several of these suggestions share no clear link to me in the online world—connections, experiences, companies, industries and school included.
Also, nowhere does it mention Twitter or Facebook data, so those theories are out. However, after perusing my LinkedIn settings, I found three different areas where Privacy Controls are listed. If you go to your Settings page and click on Profile, you will see privacy controls for a variety of profile related issues. If you click on the Account tab, you can adjust privacy controls for advertising. However, I hadn’t noticed (mainly because I didn’t think to look for privacy controls in more than one place) the privacy options under the Groups, Companies & Applications tab.
There, I found two more controls that were pre-selected:
Okay, so LinkedIn had been sharing my data with third party applications and plugins. So, maybe they are using something like Facebook to influence these suggestions? Well, not necessarily. First, they didn’t list it as a source for feeding the People You May Know feature, and second, they told me so in this reply to one of my multiple inquiries to customer support on the matter:
Well, that didn’t accomplish much. This person just reiterated what the Help Center page said. Also on a side note: The fact that they have a “Trust & Safety” team actually makes me feel more uncomfortable.
Either way, I unchecked the new-found privacy controls under Groups, Companies & Applications, only to find that a day later, LinkedIn suggested:
Tami has a total of 5 connections, lives in Seattle, no public company or title listed, but we just happened to exchange a few emails a couple days prior regarding some questions I had about software her company sold.
Last Ditch Effort…
A final thought I had was that maybe I was missing a setting within these other applications such as Facebook, allowing them to share my information with partner sites. Upon checking my Facebook controls, I found the following personalization setting:
I still believe that LinkedIn is using the search history of others to suggest “people I may know” to me, which sort of make sense. However, I am still stumped on how they came up with some of these names. I voiced my concerns to their customer support–ahem—their “Trust & Safety” team, and received only canned responses. If you have any more insight on this, I would love to hear it.
People Also Viewed…Young, Attractive Women
Okay, to close this creepiness out, we’re going to play a game. This game requires you to be a bit of a creep yourself for a moment, so if you’re uncomfortable with that, feel free to bow out now, we won’t make fun of you.
You see, LinkedIn as a company isn’t the only thing creepy about LinkedIn. In fact, it has a pretty creepy user base as well. I can prove it, too. (Note: I imagine no one has pointed this out because they don’t want to look like a creep themselves by broaching the subject. I suppose I’ll take one for the team)
The game is simple. Go through your connections and pick out the profile of someone who happens to be, in your opinion, um…a young, attractive female. Try not to feel creepy yet, this is for science.
On their profile page, take notice of the “People Also Viewed” list in the sidebar. What kind of faces do you see? Chances are, they are of more, erm, young and attractive females. If you’re a real science fanatic, click through to one of these profiles, then do it again on that profile. Within a couple clicks, you will likely be on the profile of a “model” from across the country.
In other words, “People Also Viewed” creates a public graph of creepy men’s browsing habits at work.
Thus concludes my venture into the deep, uncomfortable underbelly of social networking for professionals. LinkedIn has slipped under the radar when it comes to privacy controls and transparency, which I believe is unacceptable. Everyone points to Google, Apple and Facebook and pretty much stops there.
I’ve also always been frustrated with LinkedIn’s controls, constantly finding more boxes I need to uncheck to stop receiving notifications.
LinkedIn has experienced substantial growth in recent years, but they seem to be overstepping their bounds in certain areas. They should also keep a close eye on their users—because no one wants another Chatroulette-style takeover…
Lastly, my sincere apologies if a mustache, trench coat and wire frame glasses happen to be your look.
Creepy featured image from Jon Lajoie